Showing posts with label Government Takeover. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government Takeover. Show all posts

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Why Perdue's proposed Yadkin River takeover is so flawed

The Charlotte Observer published an opinion piece today from Rick Bowen, president of Alcoa's energy operations, about Gov. Perdue's attempted government takeover of the Yadkin Project.

Why Perdue's proposed Yadkin River takeover is so flawed

From Rick Bowen, president of Alcoa Energy

When Gov. Bev Perdue decided to pursue an unprecedented government takeover of Alcoa Power Generating Inc.'s hydropower operations along the Yadkin River, she ignored the recommendations of experts in her own state agency, disregarded the actions of the N.C. General Assembly and refused to listen to the citizens who will be most impacted by a takeover.

Instead, she asked the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to toss aside its own rules and regulations and recommend a government takeover of the Yadkin Project.

Nothing like that has ever been done before... at least not in America.

Gov. Perdue's quest to take our private property stands in stark contrast to the actions of the General Assembly, which rejected takeover legislation this year, and the N.C. Department of Environment and Natural Resources, which studied our operations and in 2007 signed the Relicensing Settlement Agreement supporting a new license for the Yadkin Project.

From the beginning, Gov. Perdue has turned a deaf ear toward the citizens most involved in this process, including homeowners, recreational users, business groups, environmental groups and others who spent years negotiating a relicensing settlement agreement with APGI that offers substantial benefits to North Carolina.

She has dismissed the recommendation of FERC staff that our license should be renewed.

And she ignored the concerns of interested citizens, including grassroots groups such as the N.C. Property Rights Coalition, who have expressed concern that this takeover will set a dangerous precedent that could impact private citizens and small business owners. You have to believe it will affect the way other business owners look at North Carolina, too.

I wish I could ask Gov. Perdue why she is so intent on taking our business. But she has refused to meet with me and others from Alcoa.

So I can't ask her why she conveniently omitted or distorted our history of environmental stewardship and community support. I can't explain that her actions reflect a clear misinterpretation of the Federal Power Act. And I can't point out the glaring errors in her filing.

For example, Gov. Perdue's projections estimate $2.8 million a year for operating and maintenance expenses - but fail to take into account any expenses associated with project land management, depreciation, other contracted costs, power substation and transmission, and general administrative expenses. Those expenses add an additional $11 million a year to the operating costs, meaning Gov. Perdue has underestimated operating expenses by almost 400 percent.

She also estimates it will cost $24.1 million to acquire the Yadkin Project. Even if a government takeover were possible, the price must reflect the updated cost of Alcoa's net investment ($91 million), plus severance damages that could add hundreds of millions of dollars to the cost.

Gov. Perdue argues that North Carolina must "secure a greater degree of control over the water supplies within its own borders." If so, then shouldn't the same rules apply to all rivers in North Carolina and all private hydro operators?

But this battle isn't about protecting the North Carolina's water supplies; it's about taking government control of a private business.

Monday, September 21, 2009

Alcoa responds to State of North Carolina's FERC Filing

On behalf of Gov. Beverly Perdue, the State of North Carolina filed a motion at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) on Friday, September 18. The filing presents North Carolina’s case for a federal takeover of the privately-owned Yadkin Hydroelectric Project in central North Carolina. Alcoa, which has owned and operated the Yadkin Project since 1917, is currently reviewing the State of North Carolina’s filing. The company has released the following statement to share its initial reaction:

We are disappointed that Gov. Perdue continues to pursue an unprecedented government takeover of Alcoa’s privately-owned hydroelectric business, despite public and legislative opposition to her efforts.

The N.C. General Assembly rejected the idea of a government takeover in August 2009 when the N.C. House voted overwhelmingly to defeat the Yadkin Trust Bill (SB 967). In addition, a public opinion poll conducted in May 2009 found that 81 percent of North Carolina voters oppose a government takeover of the Yadkin Project. The anticipated cost of a government takeover – which could be $500 million or more – and the dangerous precedent of taking private property have concerned taxpayers and legislators alike.

Alcoa believes that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has all of the information it needs to issue a new long-term license for the Yadkin Project and encourages FERC to do so. Gov. Perdue’s efforts demonstrate a complete disregard for the well-established federal relicensing process that Alcoa has followed since 2002.

Alcoa worked closely with stakeholders interested in the future management of the Yadkin River – including state agencies representing the State of North Carolina – to negotiate a relicensing agreement that has the widespread support of local governments, lakefront property owners, recreational users, business groups, environmental organizations and many others. In addition, FERC staff recommended a new long-term license for Alcoa after a comprehensive two-year review of all relevant issues.

The relicensing agreement offers significant benefits for North Carolina that are being delayed by Gov. Perdue’s actions. These benefits include improved water quality in the Yadkin River; increased water withdrawals by local municipalities; better protection of water during drought conditions; thousands of acres for long-term land protection; the creation of new parks, public swim areas and other recreation opportunities; more stable lake levels and a consistent downstream flow of water; more flexibility regarding shoreline development for lakefront property owner.

Alcoa looks forward to receiving a new license and implementing the many positive benefits the relicensing agreement will bring to the people of North Carolina.

# # #

Footnotes:

On August 6, the N.C. House voted 66-39 to defeat Senate Bill 967 (known as the Yadkin Trust bill). The bill would have established a state trust with the authority to seize the Yadkin Hydroelectric Project

McLaughlin & Associates, a respected national pollster, conducted a public opinion poll of 700 likely North Carolina voters on May 17-18, 2009. The poll found that 81 percent of voters disapproved of the state government using taxpayer money to take over a privately owned and operated business.

Friday, August 7, 2009

NC House rejects government takeover of Alcoa property in decisive vote

A great victory at the North Carolina General Assembly last night. See press release below:

NC House rejects government takeover of Alcoa property in decisive vote

N.C. RALEIGH – The N.C. House voted in overwhelming numbers to reject an unprecedented and costly government takeover of Alcoa’s hydroelectric business along the Yadkin River in central North Carolina. Senate Bill 967, sponsored by Sen. Fletcher Hartsell, failed in a floor vote by a wide margin, 66-39, with bipartisan support.

“Legislators sent a clear message that they do not support the taking of private business. The more they learned about this issue, it became evident that passing this legislation would set a dangerous precedent for North Carolina,” said Gene Ellis, an Alcoa spokesman. “We appreciate the strong support of the N.C. House and remain committed to fighting any future efforts by Gov. Perdue to take our business against our will.”

The bill would have established a state trust with the authority to seize the Yadkin Hydroelectric Project, a privately-owned business that has been generating clean renewable energy in North Carolina since 1915.

Legislators tried to quickly maneuver the bill through the General Assembly this week after the House Water Resources Committee reversed itself and voted the bill out of committee. The bill was heard twice Thursday by the House Public Utilities Committee, which passed the bill at a hastily called afternoon meeting. The bill then bypassed the House Finance Committee and was sent straight to the House floor.

Opponents of a state takeover –including lakefront homeowners, property rights advocates and local officials in Stanly County – expressed serious concerns about the proposed takeover this week. Their concerns included the potential cost to North Carolina taxpayers of $500 million or more; the fundamental violation of Alcoa’s private property rights; and the need to support the federal licensing process and the Relicensing Settlement Agreement that Alcoa reached with stakeholders.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), the federal agency that regulates hydroelectric projects in the United States, has all of the information it needs to issue a new long-term license for the Yadkin Project. FERC staff has already recommended issuing a new license to Alcoa.

“We remain eager for a new license and look forward to implementing the many positive benefits included in the Relicensing Settlement Agreement,” Ellis said.

Under the terms of the relicensing agreement, Alcoa will continue to improve water quality in the Yadkin River; allow for increased water withdrawals by local municipalities; better protect the water supply when drought conditions are present; set aside thousands of acres for long-term land protection; create new parks, public swim areas and other recreation opportunities; provide more stable lake levels and a consistent downstream flow of water; and give homeowners more flexibility regarding shoreline development.

###

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

The Battle Intensifies: House committee passes takeover bill; Sen. Hartsell maneuvers for quick floor vote

You never know what’s going to happen when you’re at the legislature. And Wednesday was one of the most surreal days I’ve ever experienced.

One week after a N.C. House Committee voted against a government takeover of the Alcoa’s Yadkin Hydroelectric Project, that same committee resurrected the bill and voted 8-7 to support an unprecedented government takeover that could cost North Carolina taxpayers more than $500 million.

The House Water Resources & Infrastructure Committee narrowly approved Senate Bill 967 despite the anticipated cost and strong opposition from lakefront homeowners, property rights advocates and local officials in Stanly County.

Within hours, Sen. Fletcher Hartsell began maneuvering the bill for a quick passage in both chambers. He amended an existing bill (House Bill 1099) to include the essence of SB 967 that creates the Yadkin Trust. The bill passed the Senate and was sent by special delivery to the House for a floor vote that could occur as early as tomorrow, effectively bypassing the House Public Utilities and House Finance committees.

At the same time, SB 967 was referred to the House Public Utilities Commission for a hearing on Thursday at 10am. This essentially gives the bill's supporters two different cracks at passing the Yadkin Trust bill. If SB 967 is defeated in committee, the full House can still pass HB 1099.

“Sen. Hartsell pulled out all the stops today. It looks like he’s willing to do whatever it takes to take away the business we started here in 1915,” said Gene Ellis, a spokesman for Alcoa. “Frankly, we’re stunned that this important legislation is being rammed through the legislature. This is a complex issue with far-reaching implications and it deserves a fair hearing.”

Alcoa will continue fighting to keep the Yadkin Project, which has generated clean, renewable energy in North Carolina for nearly 100 years. It is important to remember that regardless of what happens in the North Carolina legislature, only the federal government can consider a takeover of the Yadkin Project, Ellis said.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has all of the information it needs to issue a new long-term license for the Yadkin Project. FERC staff has already dismissed the possibility of a government takeover and recommended issuing a new license to Alcoa.

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

N.C. House Committee votes against government takeover of Alcoa’s Yadkin Project

Here is a copy of a press release we issued this evening about today's committee vote in the N.C. House.

N.C. House Committee votes against government takeover of Alcoa’s Yadkin Project

RALEIGH (July 28, 2009) – A legislative bid to pursue a government takeover of Alcoa’s Yadkin Hydroelectric Project was thwarted by a N.C. House committee today. The Water Resources and Infrastructure Committee voted 8-6 against allowing Senate Bill 967 to move forward.

“We applaud the committee for standing up for private property rights and voting against an unprecedented government takeover that could have cost North Carolina $500 million or more,” said Gene Ellis, a spokesperson for Alcoa. “We remain eager for a new license and look forward to implementing the many positive benefits included in the Relicensing Settlement Agreement.”

Under the terms of the relicensing agreement, Alcoa will:

• Continue to improve water quality in the Yadkin River

• Allow for increased water withdrawals by local municipalities

• Better protect the water supply when drought conditions are present

• Set aside thousands of acres for long-term land protection

• Create new parks, public swim areas and other recreation opportunities

• Provide more stable lake levels and a consistent downstream flow of water

• Give homeowners more flexibility regarding shoreline development

FERC staff has already recommended issuing a new long-term license to Alcoa.

“We are gratified that the House took the time to carefully consider this legislation and weigh the pros and cons. Once they did that, they voted their conscience,” said Larry Jones, president of the High Rock Lake Association. Jones addressed the committee on behalf of more than 1,000 lakefront property owners, including approximately 50 members who attended the committee meeting.

Since planting roots in North Carolina in 1915, Alcoa has been a strong supporter of the local community. Together, Alcoa and Alcoa Foundation have donated $3 million to support non-profit organizations to improve economic development, education, recreation, public safety and more.

# # #

Water Resource Committee votes against government takeover

Great news: The House Water Resource and Infrastructure Committee just voted 8-6 against allowing Senate Bill 967 to move forward. Thanks to everyone who helped make it happen. More to come soon...

Friday, July 24, 2009

NC Property Rights Coalition Begins Airing Radio Ads

The N.C. Property Rights Coalition is moving full speed ahead in its efforts to stop an unprecedented government takeover of the privately-owned Yadkin Project.

It released the following statement earlier today:

“Today, the Coalition will launch a radio ad criticizing the attempted government takeover of Alcoa’s dams and other privately owned assets along the Yadkin River. The ad will run in several media markets around the state. Click here to listen to the ad.”

For more information about the efforts of the N.C. Property Rights Coalition or to sign up to help, go to www.LeaveThatDamAlone.com.

Leave That Dam Alone

I told you yesterday that the N.C. Property Rights Coalition had joined the fight to stop a government takeover of the Yadkin Project.

Here’s some more information that you might be interested in:

The property rights folks have set up a web site – www.LeaveThatDamAlone.com – where you can learn more and sign up to help. It's worth a visit.

Water Resources Committee Meeting Scheduled for July 28

The N.C. Water Resources & Infrastructure Committee has scheduled a meeting on Tuesday, July 28 at 2pm to discuss SB 967, the government takeover bill sponsored by Sen. Fletcher Hartsell.

Committee chairman Cullie Tarleton plans to hear from two members of the public – one in favor of the bill, one opposed – then allow members to discuss the bill and consider amendments before taking a vote.

A vote in favor of SB 967 will help clear the way for North Carolina to spend $500 million or more on an unprecedented government takeover of Alcoa’s privately-owned hydro business.

If you’d like to let the committee know why they should oppose this bill, here is a list of members:

Rep. Lucy Allen: 919-733-5860, lucy.allen@ncleg.net

Rep. Hugh Blackwell: 919-733-5805, hugh.blackwell@ncleg.net

Rep. Jamie Boles: 919-733-5903, Jamie.Boles@ncleg.net

Rep. Edith Warren: 919-715-3023, edith.warren@ncleg.net

Rep. Pryor Gibson:919-715-3007, pryor.gibson@ncleg.net

Rep. Mitch Gillespie: 919-733-5862, mitchg@ncleg.net

Rep. Bruce Goforth: 919-733-5746, bruce.goforth@ncleg.net

Rep. Carolyn Justice: 919-715-9664, carolyn.justice@ncleg.net

Rep. Kelly Alexander: 919-733-5778, kelly.alexander@ncleg.net

Rep. Grey Mills: 919-733-5741, grey.mills@ncleg.net

Rep. Bill Owens: 919-733-0010, bill.owens@ncleg.net

Rep. Ray Warren: 919-715-8361, ray.warren@ncleg.net

Rep. Ruth Samuelson: 919-715-3009, ruth.samuelson@ncleg.net

Rep. Cullie Tarleton, Chair: 919-733-7727, cullie.tarleton@ncleg.net

Rep. Alice Underhill: 919-733-5853, alice.underhill@ncleg.net

Thursday, July 23, 2009

N.C. Property Rights Coalition joins the fight to stop government takeover of Alcoa’s private hydro business

A prominent property rights organization is joining the fight against a proposed government takeover of the Yadkin Project, a privately-owned hydro business along the Yadkin River.

The N.C. Property Rights Coalition, led by Raleigh lawyer Kieran Shanahan, is taking an increasingly active role in the legislative battle over a proposed government takeover of the Yadkin Project. The organization will be working to educate the people across North Carolina about the state’s unprecedented assault on private property rights. Alcoa is a financial supporter of the coalition.

If successful, the takeover of Alcoa’s privately-owned business could cost North Carolina more than $500 million and set a dangerous precedent that could make it more difficult to attract new business and jobs to our state. Business owners and individuals are asking the same question: “If this can happen to Alcoa, who’s next?”

The N.C. Property Rights Coalition took a stand on this preeminent property rights issue early on, and we welcome their support in our fight to protect our private property. We have been doing business in North Carolina since 1915 and look forward to continuing generating clean, renewable energy along the Yadkin River.

Visit http://ncpropertyrights.com/ to learn more.

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

NC business owner speaks out against government takeover of Yadkin Project, considers relocating to South Carolina

I wanted to share with you a press release that highlights the reaction of one North Carolina business owner to the government's attempt to takeover the privately-owned Yadkin Project. Rick Glenn is so troubled by the prospect of a government takeover that he plans to relocate his business to South Carolina if it happens.

The entire press release is posted below:

N.C. business owner speaks out against government takeover of Alcoa’s hydroelectric business on the Yadkin River

Bill being considered in N.C. House could allow North Carolina to seize Alcoa’s business, but it could cost North Carolina taxpayers more than $500 million

CHARLOTTE, NC – As North Carolina legislators contemplate an unprecedented government takeover of Alcoa’s privately-owned hydroelectric business on the Yadkin River, the effort is being met with resistance from North Carolina business owners like Richard Glenn, president of Glenn Underwater Services. The Charlotte-based company employs 25 people and does work on dams around the world.

Glenn moved his business from Florida to North Carolina 10 years ago. But if the State of North Carolina is successful in its effort to takeover Alcoa’s hydroelectric business along the Yadkin River, Glenn has told Gov. Perdue he will relocate his business to South Carolina.

“I have been in North Carolina for 10 years and enjoy doing business here. But I am troubled by efforts to take a privately-owned business like the Yadkin Project and believe it will result in fewer business opportunities for business owners like me,” said Glenn.

Through his business, Glenn has frequently worked in South America during the past 20 years and says he has seen this type of activity before. Glenn was working on the Guri Dam in the eastern region of Venezuela when Hugo Chavez was undertaking the acquisition of the country’s private industry.

“It started very small just like the forced acquisition of Alcoa’s Yadkin projects and ended up with a country that is now state run and has evolved from a healthy democracy to an almost certain dictatorship,” Glenn said. “During that time, Chavez was using terms such as ‘this would be best for the citizens,’ these companies are ‘sending profits overseas,’ and so forth. These exact phrases are now being used by politicians in North Carolina.”

Alcoa is fighting efforts by the state government to take the hydroelectric business it started in North Carolina in 1915.

“The government is trying to take our business and that’s an unprecedented attack on our private property rights. North Carolina doesn’t simply want to take our license away. It wants to take our dams and the land around them,” said Gene Ellis, a relicensing consultant for Alcoa.

A government takeover could cost North Carolina more than $500 million.

Responding to the NC Water Rights Committee

I don’t usually like to respond to far-fetched accusations that have absolutely no basis in fact, but I feel compelled to respond to some of the outrageous claims being made by the N.C. Water Rights Committee.

In a recent press release, the N.C. Water Rights Committee speculates that the Yadkin Project may generate as much as $80 million a year in profit and implies that Alcoa is not being truthful with its financial filings with FERC. Irresponsible allegations like that can’t go unanswered.

The financial information we have submitted to FERC is accurate and has already been independently verified by auditors. Here are the facts:

1. Alcoa Power Generating Inc. is required to follow standard accounting practices – specifically the Uniform System of Accounts (USOA) – in all financial filings at FERC. There is no “creative accounting” taking place.

2. Our annual financial filings at FERC are independently audited by PricewaterhouseCoopers to verify their accuracy. The numbers are not misleading or inaccurate.

The profit numbers being floated by the N.C. Water Rights Committee are pure fantasy. But if anyone out there can tell me how to create an $80 million profit from a business that only generates about half that in gross revenues, please give me a call.

Friday, July 17, 2009

Water Resources Committee Cancels Meeting for Next Week

The N.C. House Water Resources Committee has cancelled plans to hold another committee meeting next week regarding Senate Bill 967, the government takeover bill sponsored by Sen. Fletcher Hartsell.

The meeting, originally scheduled for Tuesday, July 21, was to provide members of the public an opportunity to share their views on the proposed government takeover of Alcoa’s Yadkin Hydroelectric Project.

I will let you know when and if the meeting is rescheduled.

Report from the NC General Assembly

I was back at the N.C. General Assembly again this week for another meeting of the N.C. House Water Resources Committee on Tuesday. The meeting was designed to give committee members an opportunity to ask questions about Senate Bill 967, a bill that would authorize North Carolina to take over Alcoa’s privately-owned hydroelectric business along the Yadkin River.

A couple of highlights worth sharing:

1. Faison Hicks, a lawyer with the N.C. Attorney General’s office who has been involved in Gov. Perdue’s push for a government takeover, acknowledged that it is impossible to know what a government takeover of the Yadkin Project would cost. Alcoa believes a takeover will cost North Carolina more than $500 million.

2. When pressed about why the legislature needed to pass Senate Bill 967 this year – without knowing the potential price tag associated with it – Mr. Hicks said it wasn’t necessary to pass this legislation for the state to continue its pursuit of a takeover. He said the state can continue its efforts at the federal level regardless of whether this bill is approved or not.

3. Richard Whisnant, a professor with the UNC School of Government who has extensively studied water issues in North Carolina, acknowledged that control of the water in the Yadkin River will still be subject to federal regulation even if North Carolina succeeds in taking over the Yadkin Project.

Committee members asked a lot of thoughtful and probing questions that underscore the complexity and uncertainty of a government takeover and the associated cost for North Carolina.

One member asked whether a takeover of the Yadkin Project would be a pilot project that could ultimately lead to a state takeover of other privately-owned hydro projects, such as those operated by Duke Energy and Progress Energy. “I don’t know,” Mr. Hicks said.

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Report from the NC General Assembly

I spent Tuesday afternoon at the NC General Assembly, speaking to members of the NC House Water Resources Committee. It is one of three House committees that is considering legislation (SB 967) that supports a government takeover of the Yadkin Project.

Here is a copy of my remarks:

My name is Gene Ellis and I represent Alcoa Power Generating Incorporated. I was born and raised in North Carolina and I have lived in Stanly County for more than 30 years. For the past seven years, I’ve been working on the relicensing of the Yadkin Hydroelectric Project.

I have to tell you, I never thought I’d see the day when the State of North Carolina contemplated taking over a private business. And that’s exactly what this State Trust bill is – the taking of a privately-owned business that Alcoa started here in 1915.

And, it could cost the state of North Carolina $500 million or more – a half-billion dollars – at a time when the state is in the midst of its worst budget crisis in years.

Some people say this bill doesn’t really do anything – it just puts a structure in place to operate the Yadkin Project if a takeover happens. But a vote to create a Yadkin River Trust is a clear indication that the General Assembly supports a government takeover despite the cost. If this bill becomes law, it will be possible for the state to pursue a government takeover.

Before I discuss the bill, let me touch on a few basic facts about the Yadkin Project.

Alcoa bought and owns the land – more than 38,000 acres along the Yadkin River, including the land underneath the lakes.

Alcoa built the dams. With our own private money and no government funding.

Alcoa has a license to run the dams, not a lease. Much like the FCC provides a license to radio stations to use the airwaves.

Alcoa provides jobs and pays taxes on its property, just like other businesses in North Carolina. In fact, we are the single largest taxpayer in Stanly County.

Alcoa’s Yadkin profits are not hundreds of millions. As stated in our new license application, we generate about $44 million a year in gross revenue, but after operating costs, taxes, depreciation and other expenses, we earn a profit of about $8 million.

Let me address the three main reasons why you should oppose Senate Bill 967 and a takeover of our hydroelectric project.

1. The cost to North Carolina taxpayers;

2. The violation of private property rights; and

3. The fact that the State of North Carolina does not need to take our dams, generating facilities and land to have control over the water in the Yadkin River.

First, Control of the Water

Supporters of this bill have expressed concern about a private company controlling the water. Alcoa doesn’t control the water in the Yadkin River.

We don’t claim to own the water. Our hydropower operations don’t consume the water – it just flows through. And we don’t determine who can withdraw water. The state and federal governments have that authority.

State law gives North Carolina the authority to regulate water use within the Yadkin River, including the right to issue new water withdrawal permits. That’s a right the state has exercised in the past by approving inter-basin transfers, most recently on the Yadkin and Catawba Rivers.

Granting Alcoa a new federal license for the Yadkin Project will not change the State of North Carolina’s ability – in any way – to control withdrawals of water.

There are 21 other privately-owned hydro businesses in North Carolina just like ours. And in each and every case, the state controls the water.

The Cost to North Carolina

Now, I would like to spend a few minutes talking about the cost of a government takeover. As I said earlier, a takeover could cost North Carolina more than $500 million.

Let me first say that we don’t believe a government takeover is possible. The deadline to pursue a government takeover expired more than three years ago, and the staff of FERC – the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission – has recommended against any further consideration of a government takeover.

In fact, the federal government has never taken over a private hydro project at the end of the license. We believe the only way for the state to take our private property is to condemn it and pay fair market value.

But let’s assume that a government takeover is possible. The Federal Power Act requires that Alcoa be reimbursed for its net investment in the Yadkin Project – a figure that is about $91 million today before being adjusted for inflation.

On top of that, Alcoa is entitled to severance damages… which would add hundreds of millions of dollars to the price tag. That’s what it would cost for Alcoa to develop comparable energy assets today.

And finally, if a government takeover did take place, the state would inherit an outstanding obligation for an additional $200 million in required upgrades and refurbishing responsibilities for the dams, generators and turbines. Because of these expenditures, Alcoa expects to operate these facilities at a negative cash flow for the next several years. The state would have to bear that same responsibility if it took over the Yadkin Project.

So, a government takeover isn’t necessary for North Carolina to control the water. And a government takeover would be extremely expensive.

Now, let’s go back to the issue of private property rights.

Taking Private Property

A few days ago, we celebrated the Fourth of July and everything that is wonderful about America. But the taking of a private business by the government goes against one of America’s fundamental values – the protection of our private property rights.

This bill would take Alcoa’s private property. And that’s not a very popular idea. A few weeks ago, we hired McLaughlin & Associates, a respected national pollster, to conduct a public opinion poll of North Carolina voters on this issue. And they spoke loud and clear.

Here’s what the voters said:

81 percent of North Carolina voters are opposed to the idea of our state government using taxpayer money to take over a privately-owned business.

63 percent oppose the government getting into the power business.

And by an overwhelming 3 to 1 margin, voters in North Carolina trust a private company to manage a hydropower project more than they would trust our state government to do it.

That final point is an issue worth discussing. Make no mistake, this is a complex business to operate. To the best of my knowledge, the state does not have any expertise in running hydro facilities or daily energy trading or transmission of power to the grid.

There has been the suggestion that the state could simply take our business and then turn around and hand it over to another private company to manage and profit from. But how can North Carolina take a business from one private company, then hand it over to someone else?

Before I finish, I would like to address a couple of other issues that have been raised.

The Environmental Issues

Let me start with the environmental issues.

Alcoa has been working with the State through the Department of Environment and Natural Resources and the Division of Waste Management for years to clean up waste sites associated with our operations in Stanly County. And you should know that these waste sites aren’t the result of Alcoa failing to follow any state or federal regulations… these are waste sites that date back to the early part of the last century, long before anyone fully understood the need to take precautions when disposing of waste materials.

The truth is, we take full responsibility for our waste sites. We’ve already spent more than $10 million on remediation efforts and have followed the direction of the state.

As I told you earlier, I live in Stanly County myself ... I’ve raised my family there, including two daughters who mean the world to me, so I care just as much as anyone else that we protect public health and the environment.

Testing has shown that these waste sites don’t pose any human or environmental threat – and the State concurs. We have agreed to continue testing and monitoring these sites to make sure they don’t pose any danger in the future. Alcoa has a permanent legal responsibility for these sites.

If there is any evidence that Alcoa needs to be doing more to clean up these waste sites, then the state of North Carolina already has the full authority to require additional steps. Taking over the Yadkin Project won’t add to the control the State already has.

The Issue of Jobs

Now, let’s talk about jobs. There has been a suggestion that our original 1958 license was conditioned on providing jobs at Alcoa’s aluminum plant in Badin. That is simply not true. If you look at the documents – and I will be happy to share them with you – you will find only a singlereference to jobs. It is mentioned in the hearing examiner documents where the length of the license is being discussed. It is not even mentioned in the license order where requirements are laid out for the Project owner.

We are all concerned about the loss of traditional manufacturing jobs in North Carolina. We worked hard to minimize the impact to our employees and our community. But, the fact is, no hydro business in America is required to support a certain number of jobs in order to receive or maintain a license. FERC staff made that point in the final Environmental Impact Statement for Yadkin it issued in 2006.

An Open Process

Last, let’s talk about process. All privately-owned hydro businesses like ours are regulated by the federal government. And the federal government has a thorough licensing process in place.

We started our effort seven years ago and we did it with the active involvement of state and federal agencies… local governments… local residents and business owners… environmental groups … and other interested stakeholders.

Those groups – nearly two dozen of them, including DENR – support a new license for Alcoa. And so has the staff of FERC. After studying this issue for two years, FERC staff issued an environmental impact statement that recommended issuing Alcoa a new long-term license for the Yadkin Project. After an equally thorough review, North Carolina’s DWQ issued a water quality certificate for the Yadkin Project, stating that Alcoa will meet all required water quality standards.

So what you have here is a situation where Alcoa followed an established, very open process involving over a hundred people… where it gained the support of state agencies representing North Carolina’s interests … where it gained the support of lakefront property owners represented by groups like High Rock Lake, Badin Lake and the Uwharrie Point Community Associations …. where it gained the support of local governments – including two communities in Stanly County – the City of Albemarle and the Town of Badin… where it gained the support of environmental groups like The Nature Conservancy and American Rivers … and where it gained the support of the staff of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.

You have all of these groups who support a new license for Alcoa. And, remember, these are groups with tremendous experience… groups who care deeply about protecting our water quality… groups that have a direct interest in how the Project and its lakes are managed.

Closing

At the end of the day, this bill is not about protecting North Carolina’s control of the water. It isnot about protecting the environment. It is not about economic development.

It is about taking private property.

It is about a dangerous precedent that threatens North Carolina’s business climate.

It is about the $500 million burden to North Carolina taxpayers.

Thank You. Mr. Chairman.